School district defends banner, consultant cost

Monday, May 05, 2008 • By Trish G. Graber • The Express-Times

TRENTON | Some of the state's poorest school districts spent thousands of dollars on consultants, travel and sports-related festivities, according to audits of 27 Abbott districts released last week.

In the Phillipsburg School District, officials spent $15,085 on banners for the 100th anniversary football game with archrival Easton.

The district also paid a consultant $50,000 to get input from the community on a new high school, the audit showed.

The information was released by the state Department of Education, which paid auditors to look at the 2004-05 and 2005-06 school years for Abbott school districts, finalizing the work required by a 2006 Supreme Court order to audit all 31 districts. Audits for Camden, Jersey City, Newark and Paterson were released last year.

The state agency used the findings to develop new rules for school districts and shape the job description of the new executive county superintendents.

Education Department officials said the new safeguards, when they are in place, will make it much less likely that some of the expenditures questioned in the audits will occur again.

"More important than some of the individual expenditures is the fact that some of those audits identified that in many of those districts they didn't have internal controls that could catch these things before they happened," said Department of Education spokeswoman Kathryn Forsyth.

The new rules give executive county superintendents the ability to comb through district budgets and eliminate noninstructional expenditures.

They also crack down on travel, prohibiting overnight stays if a conference is held within 50 miles of a traveler's home.

Under the new rules, districts will be prohibited from funding positions that are solely for public relations. They will also be barred from contracting with a public relations firm for those reasons.

Forsyth said, in addition, the Department of Education will continue to monitor the audited districts.

District superintendents said Friday that the new regulations are helpful to provide parameters, but they still defend their past spending.

"I didn't think we were out of line with what we were doing," said Phillipsburg acting Superintendent George Chando, who did not serve as head of the district during the years the expenditures took place.

In a written response to the audit, district officials said the banners were bought for a game aired nationally by ESPN, which paid a fee for the broadcasting. They also noted that the football program brought in $72,564 during the 2004-05 school year and $76,608 during the 2005-06 school year.

Phillipsburg School District officials also contended the $50,000 paid to the consultant was not only to collect data but help the district prepare for a referendum needed for a new school.

The audits of all 31 Abbott districts can be found at www.state.nj.us/education/ under the finance section.


Trish Graber is Trenton correspondent for The Express-Times. She can be reached at 609-292-5154.

Return to Articles page